Issued since 1995
Welcome to the Finance of Ukraine site (demo).
Login | Register
ACADEMY
OF FINANCIAL
MANAGEMENT
.


№ 9/2015

№ 9/2015

Fìnansi Ukr. 2015 (9): 19–44

THEORY AND HISTORY OF FINANCES

OPARIN Valerij 1, FEDOSOV Viktor 2, YUKHYMENKO Petro 3

1SHEE “Kyiv National Economic University named after Vadym Hetman”
OrcID ID : https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5181-4333
2SHEE “Kyiv National Economic University named after Vadym Hetman”
OrcID ID : https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1092-4218
3Bila Tserkva Institute of Economics and Management of  the University “Ukraine”


Ukrainian national scientific financial school: theoretical and methodological approaches


The article highlights the theoretical and methodological basis, objective background of operation, the role and importance of national scientific financial schools as a specific social institution. There are revealed approaches to national characteristics in their classification; universal and the most important arguments of legitimacy of an existence of the national scientific financial schools. It is shown the structural heterogeneity doctrinal of Ukrainian financial science in XIX — early XX century, that has not prevent the formation of distinctive national scientific financial school. In this context, the existence of Ukrainian school of finance in mid XIX — early XX century is reasoned, the peculiarities of its formation and development, characteristics, place and role in world coordinates are highlighted. It is characterised the national and special component of the leading theoretical paradigm, moreover, it is proved that it acts as starting dominant of the financial school’s internal development and has led to the world access of Ukrainian financial science to the global level. It is substantiated the necessity of studying its historical heritage considering national features. The author has grounded the hypothesis that an emergence and existence of scientific schools is criterion-significant indicator of successful financial progress of science in the country. It is proved that in the modern world, depending on national specificities, there is a special national need to develop the own concept of tactics and strategy of financial development of the state. In such circumstances, scientific schools become “points of support”, the epicenters of creation of theoretical support and financial ideology of strategic development of the country.

Keywords: finance, financial development, financial thought, financial science, scientific school, national-special, national scientific school of finance.

JEL: A11, B10, B30, B41.


Oparin V. . Ukrainian national scientific financial school: theoretical and methodological approaches / V. . Oparin, V. . Fedosov, P. . YUKHYMENKO // Фінанси України. - 2015. - № 9. - C. 19-44.

Article original in Ukrainian (pp. 19 - 44) DownloadDownloads :3011
1. Tarasov, I. (1883). Ocherki nauki finansovogo prava [Essay Science Finance law]. YAroslavl`: Tipografiya gubernskogo pravleniya [in Russian].
2. Zlupko, S. M. (2001). Vіd arxeolohіyi do ekonomіky`, rehіonіky`, kіbernety`ky` і ekohomolohіyi: vy`branі doslіdzhennya [From archeology to economics, regions, cybernetics and ekohomolohiyi: Selected studies]. L`vіv: L`vіvs`ky`j nacіonal`ny`j unіversy`tet іmenі Іvana Franka [in Ukrainian].
3. Sorvina, G. N., YAko¬vec, YU. V. (2011). Rossijskaya shkola e`konomicheskoj my`sli [Russian school of economic thought]. Moskva: Izdatel`stvo Rossijskoj akademii gosudarstvennoj sluzhby` [in Russian].
4. Bilimovich, A. D. (2008). M. I. Tugan-Baranovskij. Nekrolog [Tugan-Baranowski. Obituary]. Neizvestny`j M. I. Tugan-Baranovskij [Unknown Tugan-Baranowski]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nestor-Istoriya [in Russian].
5. Barnett, V. (2005). A History of Russian Economic Thought. L. ; N. Y. : Routledge.
6. Cvajnert, I. I. (2007). Istoriya e`konomicheskoj my`sli v Rossii. 1805—1905. Moskva: Nacional`ny`j issledovatel`skij universitet Vy`sshaya shkola e`konomiki [in Russian].
7. Sajko, E. A. (2005). Obraz kul`tury` Serebryanogo veka: kul`tur-dialog, fenomenologiya, riski, e`ffekt napominaniya [The image of the culture of the Silver Age: cultural dialogue, phenomenology, the risks, the effect of reminders]. Moskva: Prospekt [in Russian].
8. Leonenko, P. M. (2013). Metodolohіya analіzu naukovy`x shkіl u ekonomіchnіj і fіnansovіj naukax [The methodology of evaluation of scientific schools in economic and financial sciences]. Fіnansy` Ukrayiny` [Finance of Ukraine], 5, 31–49 [in Ukrainian].
9. Pertifeev, V. I. (2008). Zaby`ty`e e`konomisty` XІX veka [Forgotten economists of the nineteenth century]. YAroslavl`: Izdatel`stvo YAroslavskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta [in Russian].
10. Ryazanov, V. T. (2010). Russkaya shkola e`konomicheskoj my`sli: universal`no-vseobshhee i nacional`no-osobennoe [Russian school of economic thought: universal universal and national special]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta [Bulletin of St. Petersburg State University], 3, 66–84 [in Russian].
11. Blauh, M. (2001). Ekonomіchna teorіya v retrospekty`vі [Economic theory in retrospect]. Ky`yiv: Osnovy` [in Ukrainian].
12. Uajtxed, A. (1990). Izbranny`e raboty` po filosofii [Selected works on philosophy]. Moskva: Progress [in Russian].
13. Kudlasevy`ch, O. M. (2014). Socіal`nі aspekty` v naukovomu dorobku predstavny`kіv vіtchy`znyanoyi ekonomіchnoyi nauky` (druha polovy`na XIX — pochatok XX st.) [Social aspects of the scientific achievements of representatives of the national economic science (second half of XIX - early XX centuries).]. Ukrayins`ky`j socіum [Ukrainian society], 1 (48), 78–89 [in Ukrainian].
14. Avtonomov, V. S. (2008). Russkaya e`konomicheskaya my`sl` — zainteresovanny`j vzglyad so storony` [Russian economic thought - from the interested gaze]. Istoriya e`konomicheskoj my`sli v Rossii. 1805—1905 [The history of economic thought in Russia. 1805–1905]. Moskva: Gosudarstvenny`j universitet Vy`sshaya shkola e`konomiki [in Russian].
15. Vernadskij, V. I. (1988). Trudy` po istorii nauki v Rossii [Proceedings on the history of science in Russia]. Moskva: Nauka [in Russian].
16. Tut, za gorizontom [Here, beyond the horizon]. (2008). Voprosy` filosofii [Problems of philosophy], 11, 65–69 [in Russian].
17. de Soto, X. U. (2011). Social`no-e`konomicheskaya teoriya dinamicheskoj e`ffektivnosti [Socio-economic theory of dynamic efficiency]. CHelyabinsk: Socium [in Russian].
18. Humpeter, J. A. (2004). Istoriya e`konomicheskogo analiza [History of Economic Analysis] (Vol. 3). Sankt-Peterburg: E`konomicheskaya shkola [in Russian].
19. Abalkin, L. (2001). Rossijskaya shkola e`konomicheskoj my`sli: poisk samoopredeleniya [Russian school of economic thought: search for self-determination]. Voprosy` e`konomiki [Economics Questions], 2, 4–18 [in Russian].
20. Gegel`, G. V. F. (1974). E`nciklopediya filosofskix nauk [Encyclopedia of Philosophy] (Vol. 1). Moskva: My`sl` [in Russian].
21. Abalkin, L. I. (Ed.). (2003). Ocherki istorii rossijskoj e`konomicheskoj my`sli [Essays on the history of Russian economic thought]. Moskva: Наука [in Russian].
22. Grezneva, O. YU. (2003). Nauchny`e shkoly` (pedagogicheskij aspekt) [Scientific schools (pedagogical aspect)]. Moskva: Institut teorii obrazovaniya i pedagogiki [in Russian].
23. Grezneva, O. YU. (2004). Nauchny`e shkoly`: principy` klassifikacii [Scientific schools: principles of classification]. Vy`sshee obrazovanie v Rossii [Higher education in Russia], 5, 42–48 [in Russian].
24. Tkachenko, V. (2008). Formuvannya naukovy`x shkіl v kontekstі funkcіonuvannya totalіtarnoyi sy`stemy` v Ukrayinі (20—30-tі rr. XX st.) [Formation of scientific schools functioning in the context of a totalitarian system in Ukraine (20-30-ies. XX century.)]. Іstorіya Ukrayiny`: malovіdomі іmena, podіyi, fakty` [History of Ukraine: Little-Known Names, Events, Facts], 35, 37-51 [in Ukrainian].
25. Kun, T. (2003). Struktura nauchny`x revolyucij [Structure of Scientific Revolutions]. Moskva: Izdatel`stvo AST [in Russian].
26. Vallerstajn, I. (2004). Konec znakomogo mira: sociologiya XXІ veka [End of the familiar world: the sociology of the XXI century]. Moskva: Logos [in Russian].
27. Tokar, L. K. (n. d.). Mova v samopіznannі j samostvorennі ukrayins`koho narodu [Language in self-knowledge and self-creation of the Ukrainian people]. Zbіrny`k naukovy`x prac` NDІX [Collected Works Research Institute], t. ІХ, 27–37 [in Ukrainian].
28. Zlupko, S. M. (2006). Ekonomіchna nauka і naukoznavstvo [Economic science and the science of science]. L`vіv: Trіada plyus [in Ukrainian].
29. Zlupko, S. M. (2011). Osnovy` rehіonolohіyi [Fundamentals rehionolohiyi]. L`vіv: L`vіvs`ky`j nacіonal`ny`j unіversy`tet іmenі Іvana Franka [in Ukrainian].
30. Bojko, S. V. (2013). Ukrayins`ka naukova shkola derzhavny`x fіnansіv: іstory`chna retrospekty`va ta suchasnі realіyi [Ukrainian scientific school of public finances: historical retrospective and current realities] (Unpublished master's thesis). Ky`yiv: Ky`yivs`ky`j nacіonal`ny`j ekonomіchny`j unіversy`tet іmenі Vady`ma Het`mana [in Ukrainian].
31. Nebrat, V. V. (2012). Evolyucіya teorіyi derzhavny`x fіnansіv v Ukrayinі [Evolution theory of public finance in Ukraine]. Ky`yiv: Іnsty`tut ekonomіky` ta prohnozuvannya [in Ukrainian].
32. Yuxy`menko, P. І., L`ovochkіn, S. V., Fedosov, V. M., Yurіj, S. І. (2010). Fіnansova dumka Ukrayiny` [Financial view Ukraine]. Ky`yiv: Kondor ; Ternopіl`: Ekonomіchna dumka [in Ukrainian].
33. L`ovochkіn, S. V., Fedosov, V. M., Yurіj, S. І., Yuxy`menko, P. І. (2010). Fіnansova dumka Ukrayiny` [Financial view Ukraine] (Vol. 2). Ky`yiv: Kondor ; Ternopіl`: Ekonomіchna dumka [in Ukrainian].
34. Ky`zy`m, M. O., Ty`shhenko, O. M. (2009). Naukovі shkoly` [Scientific schools]. Xarkіv: ІNZhEK [in Ukrainian].
35. Bogomazov, G. G. (Ed.). Otechestvennaya e`konomicheskaya nauka mezhdu proshly`m i budushhim [Domestic economic science between past and future]. Sankt-Peterburg: Izdatel`stvo Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta [in Russian].
36. Smovzhenko, T. S., Steblіj, H. Ya., Horbachevs`ka, O. V. (2010). Formuvannya monetarnoyi ekonomіky` і monetarnoyi polіty`ky` Nacіonal`noho banku Ukrayiny` v kontekstі rozvy`tku svіtovoyi ekonomіchnoyi teorіyi [Formation of Monetary Economics and Monetary Policy of the National Bank of Ukraine in the context of global economics]. Ky`yiv: Unіversy`tet bankіvs`koyi spravy` Nacіonal`noho banku Ukrayiny` [in Ukrainian].
37. YAroshevskij, M. G. (1977). Lohy`ka razvy`ty`ya nauky` y` nauchnaya shkola [The logic of the development of science and scientific school]. SHkoly` v nauke [Schools in Science]. Moskva: Nauka [in Russian].
38. Stoletova, V. N. (Ed.). (1966). Nauka o nauke [Science of Science]. Moskva: Progress [in Russian].
39. YAkupov, R. I. (2012). O naukovedenii, gumanitarnom znanii i definicii ponyatiya “nauchnaya shkola” [About the science of science, humanities and the definition of the concept of "scientific school"]. Vestnik VE`GU [Bulletin VEGU], 5, 166–170 [in Russian].
40. Nort, D. (2010). Ponimanie processa e`konomicheskix izmenenij [Understanding the process of economic change]. Moskva: Vy`sshaya shkola e`konomiki [in Russian].
41. Xramov, YU. O. (2008). Naukovі shkoly` v NAN Ukrayiny` [Scientific schools in NAS Ukraine]. Nauka ta nauko¬znavstvo [Science and science of science], 4, 122–133 [in Ukrainian].
42. Zaostrovcev, A. P. (2013). Neoklassicheskij mejnstrim: torzhestvo nauchnogo metoda ili nishheta filosofii? [Neoclassical mainstream: the triumph of the scientific method or philosophy of poverty?]. Vestnik Udmurtskogo universiteta. Seriya : e`konomika i pravo [Bulletin of Udmurt University. Series: Economics and Law], 2, 31–36 [in Russian].
43. Rajnert, E`. S. (2011). Kak bogaty`e strany` stali bogaty`mi i pochemu bedny`e strany` ostayutsya bedny`mi [How the rich countries became rich and why poor countries remain poor]. Moskva: Vy`sshaya shkola e`konomiki [in Russian].
44. Zaruba, V. (2006–2007). Naukova shkola v іstory`chnіj naucі. Do postanovky` problemy` [Science school in history. By raising issues]. Ukrayina: kul`turna spadshhy`na, nacіonal`na svіdomіst`, derzhavnіst` [Ukraine: cultural heritage, national identity, statehood], 15, 769–781 [in Ukrainian].
45. Mixal`chenko, S. I. (1994). Kievskaya shkola: ocherki ob istorikax [Kyiv School: Essays of historians]. Bryansk: Izdatel`stvo BGPI [in Russian].
46. Kondrat`ev, N. D. (1923). Mixail Ivanovich Tugan-Baranovskij [Mikhail Ivanovich Tugan-Baranowski]. Pg. : Kolos [in Russian].
47. Leskyur, ZH. (1908). Obshhie i periodicheskie promy`shlenny`e krizisy` [General and periodic industrial crises]. Sankt-Peterburg [in Russian].
48. Kondrat`ev, N. D., Oparin, D. I. (1989). Bol`shie cikly` kon``yunktury`: doklady` i ix obsuzhdenie v Institute e`konomiki [Big cycles conjuncture: Reports and discussion in the Institute of Economics]. Problemy` e`konomicheskoj dinamiki [The problems of economic dynamics]. Moskva: E`konomika [in Russian].
49. Kornejchuk, B. V. (2008). E`konomicheskie vozzreniya M. I. Tugan-Baranovskogo [The economic views of Tugan-Baranowski]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nauka [in Russian].
50. YAnzhul, I. I. (2005). Экономическое значение честности (забытый фактор производства) [The economic importance of honesty (forgot a factor of production)]. Moskva: Nauka [in Russian].
51. Fedosov, V. M., Yuxy`menko, P. І. (2011). Naukovі zdobutky` predstavny`kіv Ky`yivs`koyi fіnansovoyi shkoly` kіncya XІX – pochatku XX st. [Scientific achievements of the Kiev financial school late XIX - early XX century]. Ekonomіchna teorіya [Economic theory], 4, 79–92 [in Ukrainian].
52. Blaug, M. (1994). E`konomicheskaya my`sl` v retrospektive [Economic thought in a retrospective]. Moskva: Delo Ltd [in Russian].
53. Вайнтрауб, С. (Ed.). (1981). Sovremennaya e`konomicheskaya my`sl` [Modern economic thought]. Moskva: Prohress [in Russian].
54. SHumpeter, J. A. (2001). Istoriya e`konomicheskogo analiza [History of Economic Analysis] (Vol. 1). Moskva: E`konomicheskaya shkola [in Russian].
55. Nureev, R. M. (1989). J. SHumpeter. Istoriya e`konomicheskogo analiza [Schumpeter. History of Economic Analysis]. Istoki: voprosy` istorii narodnogo xozyajstva i e`konomicheskoj my`sli [Origins: issues of the economy and the history of economic thought], 1, 236–247 [in Russian].
56. Kejns, Dzh. N. (2008). Predmet i metod politicheskoj e`konomii [The subject and method of political economy]. Moskva: Direktmedia Pablishing [in Russian].
57. Gesse, G. (2014). Igra v biser [The Glass Bead Game]. Moskva: AST [in Russian].
58. SHapiro, I. (2011). Begstvo ot real`nosti v gumanitarny`x naukax [Escape from reality in the humanities]. Moskva: Izdatel`skij dom Vy`sshej shkoly` e`konomiki [in Russian].
59. Krugman, P. (2009). Vozvrashhenie Velikoj depressii? Mirovoj krizis glazami Nobe¬levskogo laureata [Return of the Great Depression? The global crisis through the eyes of the Nobel laureate]. Moskva: E`ksmo [in Russian].
60. Horkіna, L. P., Bіla, S. O., Nebrat, V. V. (2010). Retrospekty`va ry`nkovy`x peretvoren` v Ukrayinі: suchasny`j dy`skurs [Retrospective market transformations in Ukraine: current discourse]. Ky`yiv: Іnsty`tut ekonomіky` ta prohnozuvannya [in Ukrainian].
61. Vospominaniya. S. YU. Vitte. (1960). (Vol. 2). Moskva: Soce`kgiz [in Russian].
62. Bunge, N. X. (2001). O meste, zanimaemom politicheskoj e`konomiej v sisteme narodnogo obrazovaniya i ob ee prakticheskoj deyatel`nosti [About the place occupied by the political economy of the system of public education and of its practical activity]. Іstorіya ekonomіchny`x uchen`: xrestomatіya [The history of economic studies: reader]. Ky`yiv: Znannya [in Ukrainian].